BLOG: Member Segmentation: Do we really understand our members?

We were recently invited to speak at a Roundtable series where together with association leaders we had a great conversation about spotting members' disengagement early, and how organisations can use the member onboarding journey to.

In the run-up to the Roundtable I decided to go through a number of different associations, institutes and professional bodies onboarding journeys.

It was eye opening. More often than not, very little was asked of me. I registered answering the usual questions put forward: email, full name, job title, organisation, location, phone number, communication preferences. Sometimes I was given free-text boxes to give my reasons behind joining, but to get any insights from that field you need to manually read through, utilise word-maps or use AI to give you the insights on the responses, but you may still not get the information you need to drive decision making.

In other cases, I found additional questions hidden away within my member portal once I logged in. Were I not as inquisitive, I might never have found them.

Beyond that, the association has no idea on what my motivations for joining are, my interests, what stage I am in my career, my job level, what industry I work in, my education. Basically - nothing tangible that can help the association to direct me to what I will value from the membership, only what the association thinks is valuable to me.

If you don’t understand your members, you can’t segment into different cohorts. You run the risk of treating every member the same.

Some organisations feel that by increasing the amount of questions asked during the onboarding journey runs the risk of the members giving up on the way. That is why we must only collect information with a clear purpose, rather than asking for the sake of it.

And if the member is told that by answering the questions we can shape their membership towards what they value to help them get the most out of their membership, then they are more likely to want to provide the information.

Segmenting The Members

Segmenting members allows the organisation to split vast amounts of members into smaller cohorts which can be used to tailor what we communicate to the subject the members have shown interest in through what they have told us.

Different dimensions can create multiple cohorts. Here are some examples of these segmentation dimensions and what they help us understand:

Who they are: Membership grade, career stage, sector, location, education, job level
What they want: Motivations, interests, objectives, expected benefits, communication preferences
How they behave: Engagement frequency, activity types, recency, changes in behaviour over time

Who they are and what they want are two dimensions we can gather very quickly through the onboarding process, but it does not stop there. It is recommended that you prompt your members to update their profile and interests at least once a year. This is extremely important if you want to know about existing members.

Although useful when treated in isolation, the three dimensions become particularly valuable when combined.

For example, knowing somebody is a student member is useful. Knowing they’re interested in career development, in-person networking events, want to receive mentoring or hear about job opportunities is much more useful. Knowing they haven’t engaged with any of those interests after 60 days gives the organisation something actionable.

Using Segmentation to Track Members’ First 30/60/90 Days

The first 90 days of membership provide an important opportunity to understand whether the members are finding value from their membership, and quickly.

When a member makes the decision to join, they are at their most motivated, making the first 30 days imperative to shaping how that member behaves. This is why capturing who they are and what they want from their membership as early as possible allows us to understand the member, meaning we can quickly get the member engaged in what they value, not what we think they should value.

0-30 days: First time login, first meaningful engagement, beginning to access relevant resources and benefits.

31-60 days: Further participation and behaviours start to form a pattern, members are exploring services and engaging to what aligns with their interests.

61-90 days: Repeat activity continues, or, the members start to show signs of early inactivity.

By tracking the first 90 days, segmenting members based on their motivations and behaviours, we can begin to get members engaged quicker, and start to see patterns in how the first 90 days behaviours impact renewal rates.

If a member tells us they have joined to attend events, and we regularly host one a week, and within the first 30 days they have not attended one, then that opens up a more strategic conversation about the events we host.

Using Segmentation to Track Members’ Final 90 Days Before Renewal

The beauty of segmentation is that you can flip it round. We are starting to find patterns in members' behaviour during their first 90 days, but how do behaviours leading up to renewal impact retention?

By bringing historical data together, we can begin identifying patterns in how members behave in the 90 days leading up to renewal, comparing those who subsequently renewed against those who lapsed.

For example, do members who lapse show a gradual decline in engagement? Are there particular activities or benefits that members who renew continue to use? Do members who engage across multiple services have a higher retention rate than those who only engage with one?

We can also look at how these patterns differ between segments. A member who joined primarily for professional recognition might have very little visible engagement but continue renewing year after year. Whereas a previously highly engaged member who suddenly stops attending events, accessing resources or completing learning could be showing early signs of disengagement.

By understanding these differences, we can start identifying potential risks much earlier in the membership journey, rather than waiting until the renewal reminder goes out.

More importantly, we can use what we know about those members' motivations and interests to take meaningful action, helping them rediscover the value of their membership before they reach their renewal decision.

The Key Principles to Successful Segmentation

Segmentation and tracking the first 90 days should follow these steps:

Understand - what your members are telling you through questions answered by the members

Act - on what members have told you they value, not what we assume they do.

Observe & Report - track members behaviours across the different segments

Learn - about your members. Use the data to make strategic, data-driven decisions.

Then return back to Understand.

Making Better Use of the Information We Already Have

Segmentation doesn’t have to be complicated. It doesn’t require some sophisticated technology or deep-dive analysis to understand your members. In fact, many organisations hold years of historical data about their members, but the real value comes from how that information is used.

Understanding why someone joins, what their motivations are and what they want to achieve gives us the capability to know how their behaviour changes over time. This means we have a much better opportunity to deliver a membership experience that is genuinely relevant to them.

And that is what we want to achieve. We don’t want to simply increase the number of attendees to an event, how many times members login to the portal or open and click through emails. We want to ensure that members are getting the value they expected when they made the decision to join.

The earlier and more we understand the members, the better we can tailor their experience, identify signs of disengagement early and give them a reason to renew.

Because what is the point in collecting information about our members if we’re not going to use it?


Next
Next

BLOG: Member Intelligence: going beyond traditional reporting